Grow a Soul



Bob’s talk presented at the Unitarian Fellowship of Nanaimo :

Only Connect: genetics, culture, and the veil of ignorance

Grow a language, grow a morality, grow a soul


I want to thank the Fellowship for inviting me to your service today. I want to welcome friends and family.
I have enjoyed speaking to you on several occasions and once again thank you for the opportunity. Most recently both Peter Croft and David Weston were present to question me. I miss them both.
The last time I talked with you I gave you a quiz. No quiz today! Today I want to talk about roots and soil and souls and growth. You will notice that I speak metaphorically at times and that there is in the talk a subtle (or blatant) attempt to suggest that growing tomatoes is similar to growing a soul. After the last talk one of you asked me if I am an agnostic or an atheist. I answered, “Neither. I consider myself an ignostic.”
I have been thinking about that question and answer for some time now. Perhaps a parable will help:
An ignostic was asked whether she believed in God, and said, “If you mean a big man in a cloud, as some conceive of God, then I am an atheist, for we have satellites now which would have surely seen such a creature if he existed. If you mean an all-encompassing God who is synonymous with the cosmos, then I am a theist… though I see no reason for having two words for the same thing.
Ignosticism is the position that there are many different, contradictory definitions for the word “God”, so one can’t claim to be a theist OR an atheist until one knows which definition is meant. I don’t, for example, believe in or worship Thor or Zeus or Facebook.
Furthermore, if the chosen definition is incoherent and makes no predictions that can be empirically tested, then it doesn’t matter whether one believes in it or not, for how can something meaningless be true OR false? (this last part is also known in philosophy as theological noncognitivism). And yet, of course, we humans speak and write of God. Some of us die for what we think is God. Fly planes into buildings shouting his name. God, I believe, is a character in literature in the same way that Hamlet is or that Sherlock Holmes is – an interesting, complex, fascinating character, but living only in stories.

Continue reading

Old Age!

OldReview – Old Age
A Beginner’s Guide
by Michael Kinsley
Tim Duggan Books, 2016
Review by Bob Lane, MA
May 26th 2016 (Volume 20, Issue 21)

Michael Kinsley is a columnist at Vanity Fair, a New Yorker contributor, and the founder of Slate. In his most recent book he presents a potpourri of tasty morsels of clever and serious words about life, disease, and death. The essays comprising the book include some jokes, some thoughtful considerations of how to endure a serious disease, recommendations of how to live, and a knockdown argument.

Read the review.


Note from old friend, Randal:

Coach Bob,

For your amusement—I sent this to some other friends yesterday.

Eleven armed bounty hunters in Arizona broke in and tried to arrest a 6′-3″ black man last night.
Problem is—the house is owned by a 5′-10″, white man, AND the Chief of Police!
But that doesn’t stop them, and THEY must be arrested themselves!

Apparently bounty hunters aren’t trained or regulated in Arizona, so ANYBODY who wants to carry a gun and go after people can do it. Really?

AND, the tip they were following came from Facebook, not from a reliable source like a warrant or subpoena!  – Source.

Oh, and speaking of the voting public, did you know that 34% of movie goers polled want armed guards posted in theatres!? – Source

Judging from the way the Police AND the Perps are shooting everyone down, perhaps no one should carry guns? Or everyone should carry guns? One thing is certain, our chances of getting caught in weird crossfire are increasing.